Summer Sale: Save $150 on a CGM Program
ENDS IN 00:00:00:00
Summer Sale: Save $150 on a CGM Program
ENDS IN 00:00:00:00
Use your HSA/FSA for any Nutrisense program
ENDS IN 00:00:00:00
Use your HSA/FSA for any Nutrisense program
ENDS IN 00:00:00:00
Promo code SPRING2022 will be automatically applied at checkout!

5 Healthy Sugar Substitutes to Try

Katrina Larsen, MS, RDN, CDCES

Published in Nutrition

9 min read

February 10, 2023
a plate of oatmeal with fruit and honey
a plate of oatmeal with fruit and honey

If you are looking to eat less refined sugars but still want to enjoy some sweetness every now and then, you may be wondering if sugar substitutes are a healthy option.

Sugar substitutes often have fewer calories than sugar, have a lower glycemic index, and can satisfy your sweet tooth just as well. But with so many to choose from, it can be hard to know which sugar alternatives are healthy.

Read on to learn more about sugar substitutes, their benefits, and five types you might want to try. 

Why Should I Use a Sugar Substitute?

Did you know that the average American consumes 77 grams of added sugar per day? This is more than three times the amount of sugar recommended for women. This is a frightening statistic, and even more worrisome is that much of this sugar intake comes in the form of added sugars.

Unlike natural sugars, which are found naturally in foods like fruit, added sugars have been added to a food or beverage after it has been produced or prepared. These can range from table sugar to high-fructose corn syrup.

A diet high in added sugars can increase your risk for many serious health conditions, including:

a list of risks of high added sugar consumption

The American Heart Association recommends limiting your added sugar consumption to no more than six percent of your daily calorie intake. For most people, that means eating no more than 100 calories of sugar per day, which equals about six teaspoons or 25 grams of sugar.

Sugar substitutes are sweeteners that taste very similar to sugar and can be used in its place in a variety of foods. Because many of them have zero calories, they may be a good alternative to refined sugars for people who want to reduce or limit their added sugar intake.

Many of them also have little to no effect on blood sugar and insulin production, making them safer for people who have diabetes and hyperglycemia. The majority of sugar substitutes do not interact with the bacteria in our mouths in the way that sugar does, which means they can also be much better for dental health than regular sugar.

4 Types of Sugar Substitutes

Sugar substitutes can be either natural or artificial, but because the terminology used around sugar substitutes can be inconsistent and differ from brand to brand, it can often be a little confusing to know which is which.

Let’s take a moment to learn about some of the different categories of sugar substitutes.

Natural Sweeteners

Natural sweeteners are those that come from natural sources that contain calories and nutrients that are metabolized by the body. Here are some examples of widely available natural sweeteners.

a graphic with types of natural sweeteners
  • Agave nectar
  • Raw honey
  • Date sugar
  • Maple syrup
  • Molasses
  • Sorghum
  • Stevia

Many natural sweeteners come from plant sources. Natural sweeteners are often promoted as healthier than artificial sweeteners, but keep in mind that many of them, including stevia, undergo processing and refining

Artificial Sweeteners

Artificial sweeteners are synthetic sugar substitutes that have zero or very few calories. They are about 200 times sweeter than sugar, meaning that you usually have to use less of them to get the same effect as sugar.

Here are some common artificial sweeteners. 

a list of artificial sweeteners
  • Aspartame (Equal)
  • Sucralose (Splenda)
  • Saccharin (Sweet’N Low)

Artificial sweeteners are regulated by the United States Food and Drug Administration as food additives. They have been the subject of a lot of controversy over the years, with some studies showing that they cause health problems, like the development of tumors in rats.

However, this research is heavily debated and has not been consistently proven. Some artificial sweeteners have also been shown to contribute to weight gain.  

Novel Sweeteners

Novel sweeteners such as allulose and stevia are a relatively new group of sugar substitutes. They are derived from natural sources, but are similar to artificial sweeteners in that they have very few calories.

Here are some examples of novel sweeteners.

types of novel sweeteners
  • Allulose
  • Stevia
  • Tagatose
  • Monk fruit

Sugar Alcohols

Sugar alcohols, also called polyols, are low calorie sugar substitutes. They can be artificially manufactured but some are found in fruit, vegetables, mushrooms, and algae.

Despite their name, they don’t contain sugar or alcohol, but rather low-digestible carbohydrates. Here are some examples of sugar alcohols that are available as sugar substitutes.

a list of types of sugar alcohols
  • Xylitol
  • Sorbitol
  • Erythritol
  • Mannitol

5 Healthy Sugar Substitutes

Though there are many sugar substitutes out there, there may be some options that are better for you than others. Here are five sugar substitutes that, when used in moderation, can be part of a healthy diet. 

1) Stevia

a bowl of stevia on a table

Stevia is a natural sweetener with zero calories. It is derived from a perennial shrub called Stevia rebaudiana and is often said to have a distinct aftertaste.

The sweetness in Stevia comes from compounds called stevioside and rebaudioside A and C, which are 200 to 300 times sweeter than sugar. It is available as a tabletop sugar, and is used as a sugar substitute in a number of commercial foods and beverages. 

Stevia has been shown to have a positive effect on blood sugar management and may also be a better option for people with high blood pressure. It’s also been shown to have little to no effect on insulin production, making it a more healthy alternative for people with diabetes and hyperglycemia.

2) Erythritol

Erythritol is a low calorie sugar alcohol synthesized from dialdehyde starch. This sugar substitute is used in a number of commercial products, including gum, mouth wash, candy and frozen desserts.

Like other sugar alternatives, erythritol is also anti-cariogenic, so it does not have a negative effect on dental health. This sweetener also doesn’t have an effect on glucose or insulin levels, making it a good option for people trying to manage their blood sugar. 

Some research has shown that it may have a positive effect on heart health, but more research is needed to establish a definitive link

3) Xylitol

a bowl of xylitol on a table

Xylitol is another low-calorie sugar alcohol that is used in many commercial products, like sugar-free candy, gum, baked goods, and beverages. Because it can have a positive effect on dental health, it is also used in many dental products like toothpaste and mouthwash.

Xylitol can have a positive effect on glucose tolerance and may help balance the bacteria in your gut biome. However, xylitol and other sugar alcohols have been linked to irritable bowel syndrome, bloating, gas, and other gastrointestinal issues so it is best to use it in moderation. 

One important thing to note is that xylitol is highly toxic to dogs and can cause a dangerous drop in their blood sugar. Make sure to keep products that contain xylitol out of reach of pets.

4) Monk Fruit 

Monk fruit extract, also called Luo Han Guo, is a type of fruit native to Southern China. Its sweetness comes from bioactive compounds called mogrosides, which are 100 to 250 times sweeter than sugar.

This zero calorie sweetener has not been found to have a significant effect on blood sugar. Monk fruit sweetener is used as a sugar substitute in many products, including beverages, desserts, jams and jellies, and candy.

The research on the effects of monk fruit is limited in humans, but it has been used for hundreds of years in traditional Chinese medicine. Because they are antioxidants, the mogrosides present in monk fruit may have a positive effect on inflammation.

They may also be anticarcinogenic and have antidiabetic effects. 

5) Yacon Syrup

a cup of yacon syrup

Yacon syrup comes from the yacon plant, which is native to South America. It is used there as a medicine to treat diabetes, constipation, and other health problems.

Yacon syrup is available to purchase in many grocery and health food stores and can be used to sweeten your morning coffee or tea, in baking recipes, in smoothies, or on top of pancakes. Some studies show that yacon is also effective at relieving and preventing constipation

Yacon contains many antioxidants and other healthy compounds, such as fructooligosaccharides, which can positively affect your gut bacteria, balance the ph in your colon, and increase your body’s immune response.

What is the Healthiest Sweetener to Replace Sugar?

While sugar substitutes can help reduce sugar cravings, there is no one sugar substitute that is healthier than any other. What is healthiest for you will depend on your preferences, your unique health needs, and how you plan to use it

Many of the options we’ve outlined here have a number of positive health effects, and they are all considered safe when consumed in moderation. Let’s recap some of the biggest benefits that may be derived from using sugar alternatives.

Benefits of Using Healthy Sugar Substitutes

Replacing regular sugar with a healthy sugar substitute can have a number of health benefits. Here are a few ways that switching to a sugar substitute may benefit you:

Weight Loss

a girl in workout clothes measuring her waist

A diet high in added sugar can contribute to weight gain and obesity. This is partly due to the fact that high amounts of sugar can lead to leptin resistance.

Leptin is a hormone that helps maintain body weight by signaling fullness, suppressing hunger, and regulating your energy. If your body doesn’t respond to leptin, it can lead to overeating and weight gain.

Sugar is also high in calories, an excess amount of which can lead to weight gain. Many natural sugar substitutes have very little to no calories and are not absorbed by the body, and are not likely to have a negative effect on weight. 

Dental Decay Prevention

When the bacteria in our mouths metabolizes sugar, it produces an acid that demineralizes the hard tissue of our teeth. This can lead to cavities and tooth decay

However, many sugar substitutes are non-cariogenic, meaning that the bacteria in our mouths does not metabolize them and they do not contribute to tooth decay. 

Blood Sugar Control

a girl taking her blood sugar reading

A diet high in added sugars can increase the risk of insulin resistance, high blood sugar, and type 2 diabetes. And as we now know, because many sugar substitutes are not digested or absorbed into the bloodstream, they have little to no effect on blood sugar and insulin production.

This means that sugar substitutes can potentially help to reduce the risk of diabetes and hyperglycemia. 

Related Article

Read More

Engage with Your Blood Glucose Levels with Nutrisense

Your blood sugar levels can significantly impact how your body feels and functions. That’s why stable blood glucose levels can be an important factor in supporting overall wellbeing.

With Nutrisense, you’ll be able to track your blood glucose levels over time using a CGM, so you can make lifestyle choices that support healthy living.

When you join the Nutrisense CGM program, our team of credentialed dietitians and nutritionists are available for additional support and guidance to help you reach your goals.

Ready to take the first step? Start with our quiz to see how Nutrisense can support your health.

Find the right Nutrisense program    to help you discover and reach your health potential.
Jordyn Wallerius, MS, RDN, CD

Reviewed by: Jordyn Wallerius, MS, RDN, CD

Jordyn has a bachelor’s degree in biology, a graduate degree in Human Nutrition and completed a dietetic internship at the Memphis VA. She's a dietitian at Nutrisense, and has experience working as a clinical dietitian at a VA medical center specializing in oncology and at the Mayo Clinic, working with a wide range of patients ranging from neonates in the NICU to adult ICU.

Recommended Articles